The New Achilles (Commander)

Written by Christian Cameron
Review by Elizabeth Hawksley

226 BC. Bronze Age Greece is in trouble. Once, the Achaean League, an alliance of city-states in the Peloponnese, worked together to protect themselves, but the League is weakening, and the hungry wolves of Sparta, Macedon, Egypt and Rome all want a slice. Greece badly needs a champion. Alexanor, a young warrior from Rhodes, has quarreled with his father and fled to the temple at Epidauros to train as priest and healer; he wants to heal, not destroy. When the severely-wounded Philopoemen is brought in, Alexanor fears that he will die. But Philopoemen is not fated to die; his destiny is to be the champion Greece needs; the ‘new Achilles’. The New Achilles is a thrilling roller coaster of a book, and I read it at full gallop, including an extended battle scene involving Spartans, Cretans, Rhodians and Macedonians, not to mention the superlatively brave Achaeans under Philopoemen, where, at times, I wasn’t sure what was happening and who was fighting who. Throughout the book, Philopoemen is always right.

The problem, when writing about an ideal hero (and Philopoemen, according to The Oxford Companion to Classical Literature, was ‘one of the last great men produced by Greece in the period of its decline’) is that one cannot get emotionally involved with a character who is never wrong. Readers want to identify with somebody whose personal problems force him to struggle, learn and move on – Alexanor, in fact. He’s appallingly treated by his avaricious father, who misleads him, tears him from his true love, and tries to disinherit him. Alexanor must face the difficult truth that his father is corrupt.

Unfortunately, we are just told about Alexanor’s situation, we don’t see it for ourselves, so it is less involving emotionally. Christian Cameron writes beautifully but that, alas, is not enough.