The Venetian Heretic

Written by Christian Cameron
Review by Susie Helme

Richard Hughes, an English fencing master in Venice, a former soldier and galley slave, takes in students and accommodates a studious roommate named Filippo. He teaches a woman, an opera singer of some fame.

A professor of philosophy has been murdered in Padua—a libertine. An innkeeper’s wife has gone missing, but why would the Holy Inquisition be looking for her? There are plots and intrigues, and people chasing bad guys in gondolas led by a villain in a red mask. The ticking time bomb at the end is marvellous.

The libretto for an opera becomes an instrument of dissent, and one night’s bravado in the rescue of a courtesan finds Richard fleeing by sea, pressed into fighting the Turks. He returns a war hero to play detective. Piece by piece the case unravels, as Richard gets drawn in to the plot around the heretical opera, and the matter spills beyond Italy. Do his paymasters have conflicting agendas?

The cast of characters is lush—innkeepers, merchants, courtesans, nuns, spies, Inquisatori and members of the Dieci and, of course, gondoliers. Some of them are historical—I love that. The society of cosmopolitan 17th-century Venice is complex, and Cameron doesn’t give much away. Plus, people wear masks, and not just at Carnivale. We are kept guessing at every point, plunged deeply into every scene and every conversation.

Richard is a great character for a detective—fully assimilated yet enough of an outsider that we see Venice’s exoticness through his eyes. Lovely phrases remind us. ‘Within the time it would take to say a papist Credo’; an abbess’s ‘piety [i]s stifling’; a person ‘had been in Venice long enough to learn to shrug’. When people speak with emphasis, they utter in Veneziano.

I loved this deep dive into the culture. It made me want to visit Venice, too.