Asa James

Written by Jodi Lew-Smith
Review by Valerie Adolph

In August 1875, Asa James is being raised at a ‘poor farm’ in Vermont. Not only is he an orphan, but he is of mixed race and has severe scarring on one side of his face. Shocked by an event at the orphanage, he runs away, realizing that his chances of employment are very slim. Seeing an advertisement for a tutor, he hopes his experience caring for younger orphans will help. He is fortunate to locate a family with two incorrigible boys who will accept him as their tutor. His new home, the massive but eerie Mansfield Hall, is the home of the widow Caroline Rockwell, along with some strange individuals who appear to be employed to do nothing. Asa, who has always dreamed of becoming a naturalist, harnesses the boys’ energy and curiosity to assist his research. Eventually he meets Caro. The attraction is mutual, but the strangeness and eeriness increase.

The characters in this novel are exquisitely drawn; an added bonus is the author’s sharing of her extensive knowledge of botany and genetics. The detail of Asa’s explorations into the natural world, looking for unusual life forms, adds another dimension of interest as the author conveys her own knowledge. Events occur surprisingly but naturally, keeping the pace moving and interest high. Details of late 19th-century Vermont show research not just professional but also personal, revealing behaviors and attitudes as well as the more obvious clothing and transportation. Vivid contrast is made between the beliefs and reactions of those at the poor farm and those in the mansion. This novel delves into beliefs and their effect on behaviors without becoming the least bit preachy. The result is a story not just fast-moving but thought-provoking against a fascinating background of the natural world.