Death by Misadventure

Written by Jane Bitomsky
Review by Edward James

You are familiar with ‘cosy crime’; how about ‘jolly crime’? There are two murders and one suicide in this book, but it is all narrated with verve and wit to create a very entertaining little novel. I am usually wary of genres specific to a particular era which are transposed to a different age. The classic whodunnit developed alongside the modern police force and the beginnings of forensic science, but now we find detective stories set in every age as far back as ancient Egypt. Bitomsky, however, gets away with it.

Death by Misadventure is set in 1585 in a Surrey village near Godalming, where the coroner, John Derrick, is called upon to investigate a drowning in a local millpond. The only assistants he has are twelve jurors sworn in from among the bystanders at the scene, most of them reluctant and others over-zealous. Most of the humour comes from John’s efforts to manage his unruly team.

John freely admits that he is as amateur as his team. They even have difficulty in distinguishing between a pickled cucumber and a severed penis. As he explains, he is a coroner not because he has any medical knowledge but because is rich and thus above bribery, which is how most coroners are chosen.

The story is told in two timelines: the coroner’s investigation, and alongside it the lead-up to the crime, as seen through the eyes of two teenage housemaids. Bitomsky’s knowledge of early modern judicial systems makes it seem almost credible. We feel that this is how Tudor coroners actually investigated homicides, before police forces and before forensics, and we accept that they often found it politic to record ‘death by misadventure’ rather than delve too deeply into the affairs of their neighbours.