With Love from Harlem: A Novel of Hazel Scott

Written by ReShonda Tate
Review by David J. Mason

A jazz prodigy at twenty-three, Hazel Scott’s dazzling performances at Café Society in New York City launched her as a major Harlem Renaissance figure. Scott challenged racial barriers and advocated for women’s rights. Her unbending nature, and her lasting influence in both music and equal rights, helped redefine life in America. She shared a glamorous marriage with Adam Clayton Powell, Jr., whose political career helped usher in the civil rights movements following the Harlem Renaissance. Their story of love at first sight was complicated by celebrity, public scrutiny, and conflict during a time of both opportunity and constraint.

Set primarily between 1943 and 1960, With Love from Harlem by ReShonda Tate is a captivating historical novel that merges jazz, politics and romance through the brilliant resurrection of Scott’s extraordinary life. It beautifully shows the tension between art and ambition, and Scott’s refusal to compromise makes her exceptional. The novel’s real power comes from how it shows Scott as both a famous performer and a woman dealing with her own struggles and those of society.

What sets Tate’s storytelling apart is her focus on character-driven narrative. Scenes depicting Scott’s advocacy for equal rights, such as her refusal of minstrel show acting roles or performances in segregated venues, highlight the intersection of the art and activism that defines her legacy. The presence of prominent figures from that era, including Billie Holiday, Langston Hughes and James Baldwin, makes it particularly fascinating.

With Love from Harlem meticulously blends historical accuracy with convincing and emotional prose to create an immersive novel. Although historical fiction, the book might have benefited from a more in-depth exploration of events that unfolded around Scott. I highly recommend this vivid portrait of Scott’s artistry and activism.