Whistling Women and Crowing Hens

Written by Melora Fern
Review by Marcy McNally

1924, East Coast US. Nineteen-year-old Bertha “Birdie” Stauffer, a gifted trombonist and concert whistler, is selected to tour with the Chautauqua circuit’s prestigious, all-women musical ensemble. Longing for independence and the excitement of the Roaring Twenties, Birdie has the chance to escape her domineering older sister’s control and break away from the constraints of small-town living by performing with the Versatile Quintet. As she and four eager, ambitious young ladies travel by train, presenting their unique act in numerous east coast cities and towns, Birdie learns more about herself and human nature than she thought possible. From her evolving relationships with colorful colleagues, unconventional romantic encounters, to facing complex family issues, she experiences heartbreak and happiness in new and surprising ways.

Fern’s debut novel is a captivating story filled with intriguing twists and turns in both plot and character development. The 1920s are vividly brought to life through the author’s detailed descriptions and lively, often amusing dialogue. The robust cast of eccentric characters, each with their own quirks and charm, is one of the book’s strongest elements. Heroine Birdie is an immediate draw – spirited, vulnerable, talented, and resilient, who undergoes a significant transformation from a naïve young girl to a confident and liberated woman. The others in the quintet are fully developed and add the perfect layers of intimacy to the well-structured plot. This journey of self-discovery is a fascinating tale told with humor and pathos. A memorable, enjoyable read!