Unpapered Bedroom Murder in a Nutshell

Written by Frances McNamara
Review by K. M. Sandrick

The December 16, 1924, crime scene: a woman’s body lies under a woolen blanket on a thin mattress in a tenement room whose walls have been stripped of their wallpaper and its tile floors worn and scuffed. A pair of high heels and a suitcase in front of the iron bedstead, an outdated calendar above. The details sketched out and later transformed into a miniature study of crime scene investigation.

Unpapered Bedrooom Murder in a Nutshell is the fourth in McNamara’s Nutshell Murder Mystery series. The novels build on the work of Frances Glessner Lee, who funded the Harvard Department of Legal Medicine, worked with Jake Magrath, the first medical examiner of the northern district of Boston, and created the diorama Nutshell Studies of Unexplained Death to train homicide investigators.

The novel reacquaints readers with previous Nutshell mysteries’ characters and settings and their contrasts: the Harvard-educated neophyte investigator Peter Attwood and the experienced but demoted Irish policeman Mack McNally, Brahmin society and the working class. It also features a high-profile 1920s crime—this time the prosecution and execution of Italian immigrant/anarchists Sacco and Vanzetti and the questionable handling of ballistics in their case.

The book follows standard mystery norms as it moves from suspect to suspect. Much of the narrative covers the same ground without shedding new light or frankly making the best use of evidence, however. Investigators ask leading questions instead of sitting back and letting subjects speak for themselves, so they end up falling into their own traps. Investigators use forensics to understand how crime was committed instead of narrowing down the field of suspects and leading directly to the perpetrator.

Often interesting, certainly twisty, but a little papered over.