The Maiden of All Our Desires

Written by Peter Manseau
Review by Peggy Kurkowski

Faith, love, and loss in the time of the Black Death are hypnotically portrayed in The Maiden of All Our Desires by Peter Manseau. Set in 14th-century Europe, this elegiac novel follows an order of nuns in a remote German abbey, founded by the inimitable and charismatic Mother Ursula. After her departure, Ursula’s pet and most devoted follower, Sister John, becomes the new mother who often closes out the daily liturgy with a reading from Ursula’s own writings. Soon, the faint whiff of heresy from this alleged “Book of Ursula” wafts into the church’s male hierarchy, and an investigation is launched. While both Ursula and Mother John have their own troubled backstories, so does the priest sent to minister to the nuns, Father Francis. Banished to the isolated spiritual outpost, this woodcarver’s son strives to find redemption for a horrible sin that haunts his waking hours. While the sisters of the order take sides in the heresy investigation, one of the bishop’s inquisitors makes a deep impression upon Sister Magdalene, the youngest sister, who hears the wind call out her real name during a deadly blizzard. Behind and around it all is the horrific landscape of the Black Death that literally knocks upon the abbey’s door and wreaks a terrible toll upon body and spirit.

The Maiden of All Our Desires is a thoughtful exploration of freedom, love, and regret during a time of apocalyptic tragedy, but it requires close reading to manage the leaps of time and place in each of the main characters’ minds. Overall, readers will enjoy this spiritual, literary tale that provides what life didn’t in plague times—a satisfying conclusion.