The Soup Kitchen Girl

Written by Libby Ashworth
Review by Sarah Johnson

Ashworth’s latest saga, first in a series, does a commendable job weaving documented local history into an engaging story of women’s friendship amid economic trauma. The background is enlightening, a less familiar angle on the US Civil War’s far-reaching effects. In 1861, with the Union’s blockade of Confederate ports, Lancashire mills were forced to shutter, since they lacked the raw materials – imported Southern cotton – they’d relied upon. The “Cotton Crisis” led to widespread unemployment and poverty in the industrial town of Blackburn, where this entry takes place. (The conditions of enslavement which produced the cotton aren’t addressed in this story but are covered in the author’s note.)

Ashworth uses a successful saga model in depicting three young women from different classes and how their unexpected bond helps them endure. Ruth Hodgson works in her widowed father’s confectionery, but few can afford sweet indulgences, so Mr. Hodgson closes the shop after Christmas and takes up supervising a soup kitchen organized by a relief committee; Ruth, to her chagrin, is asked to prepare the food. Former mill girl Sally Grimes, eldest in a large family with dwindling finances, has the cooking experience Ruth lacks. Hating to accept charity, her proud father makes plans to relocate them to America. When mill owner’s daughter Caroline Haworth, in her full crinoline skirt, secretly leaves her home to help in the kitchen, she meets with derision, but despite her naivete, her heart is in the right place. All three are sympathetic and well-rounded, and each has problems at home, not just monetary, that irrevocably change their lives.

Fine details enrich the setting, from the Hodgsons’ carefully crafted sugar mice to the uncomfortable quiet of Blackburn’s streets without the mills running. It’s a moving slice of social history rendered via fiction, and I eagerly await volume two.