The Year the Swans Came
In a town still recovering from the aftermath of invaders, Magrit aka “Maidy” is turning 16, an age heralding womanhood. However, birthdays haven’t been very joyous since the disappearance of her older brother Pieter six years ago. On the morning of her birthday, a flock of swans arrive, which villagers consider an ill omen. Then at school, Maidy and best friend Ruth meet four handsome new students. Another surprise awaits Maidy when she returns home, her brother Pieter! Ruth and Pieter begin courting, but harsh truths involving Ruth, Pieter, and the four mysterious students will crumble the foundations of Maidy’s world and uncover a long-forgotten magical curse.
In an “Ask the Author” question, Spencer shares that her book is set in 1951-1952 in Holland, which makes sense though isn’t otherwise mentioned. The literary allusions about life and the world are quite lovely. Spencer has unique ways to describe the setting, which I relished. However, there are awkward phrases, too, one example being “don’t let’s fall out.” Fantasy elements are sparse, but the plot has plenty of twists to keep readers engaged. Character-wise, though, Maidy has a severe case of “doormat” syndrome—letting everyone walk over her. Maidy also justifies the unhealthy relationships ruining her family dynamic. While Maidy’s own reflections call out this fact, pondering her part in the tragic play she’s found herself in, her lack of influence on the plot undermines character development. Ruth has an interesting backstory, but it’s never realized and only used to poorly excuse her behavior.
The ending is sudden, and I was left wondering why a significant moment hinged on superficial words instead of genuine feelings. It makes one character’s plotline too simplistic. While the book lacks relatable characters, its prose is beautiful. Spencer is a word artist, painting settings with expert pen strokes.
