The Redemption of Philip Thane (Penhallow Dynasty, 6)

Written by Lisa Berne
Review by Katie Stine

In this novel set in the English countryside in 1819, Philip Thane is up to no good. He is, of course, broke. When he approaches an elderly rich relation for cash, she agrees to an exchange: a speech must be delivered in Whittlesey for Plough Day. Off Philip Thane goes to Whittlesey with gritted teeth. The next day, he delivers a short, cringeworthy speech and tries to leave, but he can’t. He returns to Whittlesey, but when Philip Thane wakes up the next day, it’s Plough Day again. And again.

Based on the same conceit as the Bill Murray movie Groundhog Day, Philip Thane must go through the same day until he manages to become a person who can recognize that other people have souls, wants, and aims different from his own. Fortunately, Miss Margaret Allen, a wide-eyed bluestocking, is spared from remembering his behavior day to day because much of it early on is unforgiveable.

This is an enjoyable, sweet read, ticking the boxes of a romp. Philip receives gratifying comeuppance as he first attempts to indulge his vices, only to learn that personal growth is more rewarding, and the struggle is the most important part of the journey.